For the brief years I taught math, the day I dreaded most each year was the introduction of long division. I have to say that teaching quotation marks is my writing equivalent. After years and years of quotation mark fails, I found what usually works best for my students. The summary of that is: start early and practice every single week. The skill is simply too complex to pick up quickly, no matter how old or young you are.
I usually introduce this skill as early as week three. I do a quick mini-lesson using the anchor chart below. If you have a student working from home or want to send a lesson home to parents, here is the best one I have found on Youtube.
![](https://teachingwithouttwitching.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/quotation_mark_anchor_chart.jpg?w=480)
I try not to make this super long. I read number one on the list and show them the difference with a short example I write on the board:
He told her he needed to find his pencil.
He said, ¨I need to find my pencil.¨
I read number two on the list and explain that the quotation marks indicate to the reader that the narrator is no longer speaking. This can be a little tricky with first person because there are times when a first person narrator´s words show up in quotation marks, but that is usually when the narrator speaks to another character, not to the reader. I do not bring this up on day one, but when we encounter it in a passage, I point it out. I almost always have a student who, once introduced to quotation marks, begins to use them all over the place when they write in first person. I have this discussion with them right away and find examples in classroom library books to show them.
I read number three and show them what this looks like using classroom library books. Some kids pick this up immediately in their own writing from that point on. Others are just not ready. I tend to leave this alone until they master using quotations at the sentence level. Then, I bring it up again.
Lastly, I introduce pattern one and pattern two. I model writing one of each on the board. I explain there are other quotation mark patterns and even other uses besides dialogue for quotation marks, but we are going to master pattern one and two before we learn anything else. I often have advanced students seek out other patterns in their library books just because I refuse to show them in advance. They are so excited when they find them on their own, and so am I!
After the lesson, I use my weekly bell work to model to students how to use pattern one and two to identify correct or incorrect usage of quotation marks. I have found that I need to do the first two boxes together this first day. I call up a partner for myself and model talking/arguing through each part of the pattern to see if it is correct. The kids really love learning how to have a discussion like this. Then, we do partners for the last two boxes. I like to do partner bell work each Friday, and the kids look forward to these conversations. I have found the kids learn more quickly about quotation marks through this weekly partner method than any other way I have tried.
Once I have taught quotation marks to the group, I can start having discussions about quotation marks in their workshop writing. However, if a student has not mastered basic end punctuation, they are not ready for quotation marks. I only have conversations about quotation marks in workshop if they are ready for them. If you try to push them in advance of end punctuation, you will end up with an even bigger mess on your hands.
I hope this helps, and I would love to hear what has worked for you.